top of page

WISH-LIST WEDNESDAY: Teeth

Writer: James Tradgett
James Tradgett
Oct 28
2 min read

PREMIERED: 2024 (Playwrights Horizons, NYC)

MUSIC/BOOK: Anna K. Jacobs

LYRICS/BOOK: Michael R. Jackson

-----

Official artwork for "Teeth"
Official artwork for "Teeth"

There's unhinged musicals, and then there's this recent musical adaptation of a bizarre cult classic movie, as this week, rather than showcasing a work that I’ve not seen, I am instead featuring one that has yet to make its European premiere, but that I feel audiences over would majorly connect with due to its superbly surreal subject matter and how well it parodies US abstinence and youth pastor culture. Based on the 2007 horror film of the same name by Mitchell Lichtenstein, "Teeth" is a satirical look at religious purity culture and its often toxic nature, as well as bodily autonomy in women especially, as we follow high school student Dawn O'Keefe, who is born with what is commonly referred to as "Vagina Dentata" (which is exactly what it sounds like).


What ensues is a series of encounters that challenge how Dawn sees herself, from the submissive, timid girl who fears her own body, to the fierce, quasi-possessed she devil who, triggered by one too many misogynists, proceeds to partake in a ruthless spree of intimidation and emasculation, along with her trusty "promise keeper girls". Anna K. Jacobs and Michael R. Jackson have arguably created something that, though gruesome and grisly on the surface, actually has a great deal of depth to it, and its innate ridiculousness just adds majorly to its appeal, from the hugely exaggerated nature of the youth pastor, to the complete and utter deterioration of proceedings in the final part, and the anthemic, hard rocking "Dentata" whipping us all into a frenzy.


Alyse Alan Louis in "Teeth"
Alyse Alan Louis in "Teeth"

The show first premiered at the Playwright's Horizons off-broadway in 2024, later transferring to New World Stages for a subsidiary run later that same year, and proved rather polarising but generally favourable among critics, with notable members of the cast including "Maybe Happy Ending" star Helen J Shen, and Olivier winner and Tony nominee Andy Karl. Though traditional audiences would likely keep this one at arm's length, there is no doubt that there is an audience for this wild, wacky, and brilliantly bonkers new musical, so there is no reason why this couldn't be a success on this side of the Atlantic.


-----

Let me know if you saw this in New York, and check out my review of the show here.

Comments


© 2025 by TheatreTradge

bottom of page